Should I Get My Engine Replaced or Buy a New Car?

April 15, 2021
Should I Get My Engine Replaced or Buy a New Car?

It is no secret that vehicle troubles are less than ideal. The worst-case scenario for many drivers is finding themselves with a blown engine. So can your engine problems be repaired? Is an engine replacement worth it? Or should you invest in a new vehicle? The mechanics at Chapel Hill Tire are here to answer all of your engine replacement questions.

 

Can My Engine Be Repaired?


One of the most common questions from drivers with engine troubles is, “Can my engine be repaired?” You can bring your vehicle to a mechanic to explore whether an engine repair is a viable option. There are three common outcomes for your engine concerns: maintenance services, a single part or system replacement, and a blown engine.

 

Maintenance Service for Engine Troubles


Maintenance services are preventative measures meant to protect your engine. At the first signs of vehicle trouble, you may be able to address your engine concerns with maintenance instead of repairs. The key here is to get your engine in the shop before it becomes damaged. Maintenance solutions, likeengine fluid flushes, will also depend on the source of your engine problems and how severe the problem has become.

 

Maintenance can occasionally address early-stage engine concerns before they develop into serious issues. However,it is best to keep up with routine automotive maintenance to avoid any close encounters with engine damage.

 

Engine Repair: Single Part or System Replacement


Once your engine troubles have progressed into damage, you will begin to explore repair options. If your engine damage is contained to a single part or system, you may be able to achieve a repair by addressing the source of these issues. In a best-case scenario, you may simply need a replacement belt or hose. Larger systems, such as with the transmission or radiator, will be more costly to replace, but they are still less expensive than a new vehicle or an entire engine replacement.

 

Blown Engines


Your engine is a network of connected parts and systems. When an engine faces severe damage, it can quickly spread from one component to the next. Repairing your engine at this stage is often not an option. Instead, you will need to explore your replacement options—for your engine or your vehicle.


Engine Replacement—Is it Worth It? 


Engine replacement is often a more affordable solution to vehicle replacement. You might be wondering, “Is engine replacement worth it for me?” Here is a look at some of the signs that engine replacement is the right option for you:


  • Warranty coverage: If your vehicle is new and covered under warranty, engine replacement is an easy choice. This coverage will provide you with a like-new vehicle at little or no cost to you.

 

  • Insurance coverage: Much like warranty coverage, if your insurance will pay for your engine replacement service, you could again get a like-new vehicle at little or no cost to you.

 

  • Cost savings: Even without warranties or insurance help, engine replacement is often more affordable than buying a vehicle replacement.

 

  • Reliable repair: Are you choosing between an engine replacement and an older used vehicle? This may be a sign that you need a new engine. New engines offer a long-term, reliable solution to your car troubles. On the other hand, used vehicles may come with their own set of engine problems. If your used vehicle replacement encounters engine issues, you could end up paying twice as much in the long run.


  • Sentimental value: Sometimes, a car is more than just a car. Perhaps your vehicle is a family heirloom? Maybe it once belonged to someone you loved? Or possibly it was a special gift that you cherish? In these cases, an engine replacement can help you keep your vehicle and the memories it holds.


Considering an engine replacement? Get a professional evaluation at Chapel Hill Tire today.


New Vehicle vs. Engine Replacement


While engine replacement is a reliable solution, it is not for everyone. Some drivers will instead opt to buy a new vehicle. Here are some signs that a vehicle replacement may be right for you:


  • Needed Upgrades: If you are seeking an upgraded space or new features, a vehicle replacement might be the right option for you.


  • Higher budget: While engine replacement is costly, it is often much cheaper than a new vehicle. If you have a larger budget to spend on your vehicle, you might consider opting for a new car. As mentioned above, a cheaper vehicle replacement can encounter issues that leave you paying double—so we would only recommend vehicle replacement if you have the budget to get a reliable car with a warranty.


  • Other failing components: For some drivers, replacing their engine leaves them with a like-new vehicle that will last for years to come. For other drivers, the engine is just the beginning of their vehicle troubles. If your car is experiencing issues with theHVAC, frame, catalytic converter, suspension, headlights, and other system components beyond the engine, you may consider replacing it instead.

 

Remanufactured Engines: Your Replacement Middleground


Remanufactured engines are engines that have been previously repaired and restored. They offer an alternative solution to both new engine installations and vehicle replacements. Remanufactured engines are more affordable than new engines while still offering a reliable solution to your vehicle problems.


If you are wary about installing a remanufactured engine, consider partnering with a mechanic that offers a service warranty. Chapel Hill Tire, for example, extends our 3-year/36,000-mile service warranty to remanufactured engines to give drivers peace of mind and protection.


Chapel Hill Tire Engine Replacement Services


The local mechanics at Chapel Hill Tire install both new and remanufactured engines. We also have FREE loaner vehicles to keep you on the go while we take care of your vehicle. You can find our mechanics in Chapel Hill, Cary, Durham, Raleigh, Carrboro, and Apex. We also serve surrounding communities like Knightdale, Wake Forest, Clayton, Morrisville, Garner, Pittsboro, Hillsborough, and beyond. You can make an appointment here online to get started with your engine service today!

We’ve got all your automotive repair needs covered.

A row of black tires are stacked on top of each other.
By Erin Vernon May 14, 2025
Brakes stop your wheels, but tires are what really stops your car.
A bottle of green liquid is being poured into a car radiator.
By Marc Pons May 8, 2025
It can be hard to keep up with all of the care that your vehicle needs. When a light comes on in your dashboard or a mechanic lets you know you are due for a new service, this can surface lots of questions. One common source of service confusion is the coolant flush. Thankfully, Chapel Hill Tire has you covered. Here is a look at the answers to all of your common coolant flush questions. Is it Really Necessary to Flush Coolant? Perhaps the most common question surrounding this service is, “Are coolant flushes really necessary?” The short answer is YES.  Your engine creates friction and heat in order to run properly. However, your engine is also made of metal pieces, which are malleable and vulnerable when heated. Extensive heat can cause a blown radiator, cracked gasket head, warped cylinder, and melted seals, among numerous other serious, dangerous, and expensive issues. To protect your engine from this heat, your radiator contains coolant that absorbs excess heat. Over time, your coolant will become worn out, burnt, and contaminated, causing it to lose its cooling properties. While you might not like hearing that you are due for an extra service, coolant flushes are necessary for a safe and healthy vehicle. Does Coolant Matter During Cold Weather? As we approach the fall and winter temperatures, you may become increasingly tempted to ignore coolant services. Does coolant matter in the cold weather? Yes—the friction and power of your engine generate heat year-round. While the summer temperatures certainly do intensify engine heating, coolant is still incredibly important in the winter. Additionally, coolant contains antifreeze, which will protect your engine from the dangers of cold temperatures. What is the Difference Between Coolant and Radiator Fluid? When reading your owner’s manual or various resources online, you might find “coolant” and “radiator fluid” terms used interchangeably. So are they the same thing? Yes! Radiator fluid and coolant are different names for the same material. You might also find it referenced as “radiator coolant,” which offers the best of both worlds. Is Coolant the Same as Antifreeze? Another common question that drivers ask—“Is antifreeze the same thing as coolant?” No, these two are not quite the same. Rather, coolant is the substance used to regulate the temperature of your engine. Antifreeze is the substance within your coolant that prevents freezing in the winter. You might find some sources that refer to coolant as providing cooling properties only; however, since the coolant often contains antifreeze, it has widely become a general term that encompasses both. How Frequently Are Coolant Flushes Needed? Generally speaking, a coolant flush is often needed every five years or 30,000-40,000 miles. However, coolant flush cadence can be impacted by your driving patterns, local climate, vehicle age, make, and model, as well as other factors. Consult your owner’s manual or a local professional for insight on whether or not you are due for a coolant flush. Additionally, you can look for signs of a needed coolant flush. These include a sweet maple syrup car smell and vehicle engine overheating. Take a closer look at these and other signs of a needed coolant flush here . How Much Does a Coolant Flush Cost? Many mechanics try to hide their prices from customers, which can create questions, confusion, and unpleasant surprises. While we cannot speak for the costs you will face at other mechanic shops, Chapel Hill Tire offers transparent pricing for every coolant flush and other services . Our coolant flushes cost $161.80, which includes the safe disposal of your contaminated fluid, professional-grade cleaning of your cooling system to remove rust and sludge, high-quality new coolant, coolant conditioner to keep it preserved, and a visual inspection of your entire cooling system. Chapel Hill Tire: Local Coolant Flush When you are due for your next coolant flush, visit one of Chapel Hill Tire’s eight Triangle-area locations, including our mechanics in Raleigh, Durham, Carrboro, and Chapel Hill. Our professionals will help you drive happy by getting you in, out, and on your way with fresh coolant. Make your coolant flush appointment today to get started!
A close up of a car engine with oil being poured into a bucket.
By Marc Pons May 5, 2025
Oil Change Prices Why do most mechanics and dealerships hide the costs of their services? You might be wondering if they will try to take advantage of your visit and overprice their services. Or perhaps they think that their oil changes are so expensive that displaying their service costs would deter customers from visiting the shop. At Chapel Hill Tire, we value our customers, which is why we display transparent pricing for all of our services. Here is everything you need to know about the actual price of oil changes. What Does an Oil Change Involve? One of the most common vehicle services—and arguably the most important for keeping your engine protected—is the oil change . This product keeps your engine lubricated so that it can function without harmful friction. Over time, your oil becomes filled with debris, making it less effective in providing proper protection for your engine. Your oil levels also become depleted as your engine burns through your oil supply. This is where an oil change comes in. Not only do you need to supply your vehicle with oil, but you also need to remove the old oil and replace the filter that prevents the harmful debris from entering your engine. If you partner with an outstanding oil change expert, you will also receive routine vehicle checks included in the price of your oil change. On average, you need an oil change every 3,000 miles or every six months , whichever comes sooner. Maintaining regular oil change services will keep your vehicle protected and prevent costly engine damage from occurring. How Much Does an Oil Change Actually Cost? Every mechanic has to price their oil changes in a way that helps keep business open. However, you want to ensure that this number does not take advantage of your visit. Here is how much an oil change actually costs your mechanic: Oil Costs : Perhaps the most obvious expense, the mechanic will pay for several quarts of oil to fill your reserve. There are multiple different types of oil that vary in thickness, which can affect your oil change costs. If you take a look at your oil cap, it will tell you which type of oil your engine requires. Labor Cost : Here, you pay for the years of experience and the professional care provided by your oil change technician. You also reap the convenience of having an expert take care of your vehicle. Filter Cost : Your oil filter keeps contaminants out of your engine. These contaminants can wear away at your filter over time, which is why you require regular filter replacements. The cost of your filter may vary slightly depending on your vehicle make, model, trim, and year. Disposing of Used Oil Cost : Part of the hassle of an at-home oil change is navigating the disposal of the old, messy, and contaminated oil. An expert mechanic has the resources and an established process to ethically dispose of old oil. Collectively, what you pay will reflect the cost of the oil change for your mechanic. Even with all of these offerings, oil changes are often reasonably priced—usually running between $40-$70. You can also find oil change coupons to help offset the cost of this service. Transparent Oil Change Prices You won’t find hidden costs here at Chapel Hill Tire. Instead, we keep all of our prices clear and transparent on our services page . The only variance possible in this price is if your vehicle requires a filter or oil that is non-standard or higher in cost. This price includes five quarts of oil, an oil filter change, an air filter check, a fluid levels check, an inspection of your belts and hoses, and a tire air pressure check. Visit Chapel Hill Tire | Oil Changes with Transparent Prices If you are ready to ditch the traditional hidden oil change costs, visit your local Chapel Hill Tire location. With 8 Triangle-area shops—including mechanics in Raleigh , Chapel Hill , Durham , and Carrboro —you can get a quick and affordable expert oil change no matter where your day takes you. Schedule your Chapel Hill Tire oil change today to get started!
A man is changing a tire on a machine.
March 25, 2025
Buying new tires can feel overwhelming—there’s plenty to consider, from price and brand to performance and safety. To simplify this essential purchase, this guide walks you step-by-step through choosing the right tires for your vehicle, ensuring you get the best value and performance for your investment.
A person is fixing a tire with a screwdriver
March 24, 2025
Fix-a-Flat is a popular liquid tire sealant meant to seal small punctures in a tire and is regularly used by drivers looking for a quick solution to a flat tire. While many people use Fix-a-Flat, it can cause more problems than it solves, and most mechanics won’t recommend you use it. As you decide whether you should keep a spare can of Fix-a-Flat in your car or garage, take a moment to learn why Fix-a-Flat and other similar products can be bad for tires and what to use instead when you get a flat.
A car with a chapel hill sticker on it
By Jess Cervantes March 10, 2025
Wondering how to properly clean pollen off your car? Chapel Hill Tire can help. Review our guide to protecting your car from pollen damage today!
A car is driving down a road with a circle around it
By Mike Storey March 10, 2025
Want to learn more about modern safety features in cars? Chapel Hill Tire can help. Review our guide to the 5 main types of vehicle safety features.
An electric car is being charged at a charging station
By Emma Baker March 10, 2025
Wondering how many EV charging stations there are in Chapel Hill, North Carolina? Review our guide to Chapel Hill EV chargers and a directory of them!
A stack of tires sitting on top of each other on a shelf.
By Marc Pons February 18, 2025
Wondering when you need to buy new tires for your vehicle? Chapel Hill Tire can help. Review our guide about when to replace your vehicle's tires today!
A woman is adjusting the air conditioning in her car
By Marc Pons February 14, 2025
If you need to get your car's AC system working before the warm weather sets in, Chapel Hill Tire has the insight you need to get & keep your AC working.
Show More